www.ringsideboxingshow.com


Rizwaan
Zahid

Tomasz Adamek

 

Haye and Adamek:
Report card after three tests


By Rizwaan Zahid
of The Boxing Amusement Park


Both David Haye and Tomasz Adamek have taken advantage of the disappointing heavyweight division recently. Unlike most predecessors who have moved up from cruiserweight or light heavyweight, both Adamek and Haye have had some success against the big boys. Since moving to the division permanently, each fighter has won all three of his bouts, albeit against six different opponents. Here is an analysis on which fighter has had the tougher opposition,  and which has the better future as a heavyweight fighter.

Fight #1 – Barrett and Golota
Monte Barrett has had his moments as a heavyweight fighter with wins over prospects Dominick Guinn and Owen Beck. But he was 37 when he fought Haye -- well past what would’ve been considered his prime. Haye wiped the floor with him. as expected.
Meanwhile Adamek fought the man with the bigger punch -- Golota -- but "The Foul Pole" brought in a ton of extra poundage. Even when he was in his late 30’s, Golota always came into a fight soundly in shape. This fight however, he weighed in an Arreola-like 256 pounds. At 42, he too was past his best. Both results were a TKO in the 5th for Haye and Adamek. We can call this one a draw.

Fight #2 – Valuev and Estrada
Valuev may be big, but he’s a waste of space. Haye used his natural speed and athleticism to beat the 36 year old. Against Estrada, Adamek used his athleticism as well, beating the wider man to the punch en route to a comfortable decision. Neither performance was necessarily outstanding as both fighters simply did their job. Haye may get the nod here just because he was fighting Valuev in his home country and a fighter who has a bigger (but definitely slower) punch.

Fight #3 – Ruiz and Arreola
This was the first real test for either fighter and both passed comfortably. The difference here is that Ruiz was 38 at fight time. while Arreola was 29. Arreola also is by far the bigger man  and packs a bigger punch. Also, despite being 250 pounds, Arreola can move quite a bit for a man his size and can put combinations together. Ruiz was well past his better days and Arreola, despite losing two of his last three, is still a major threat for anyone in the division, including David Haye. Haye has acknowledged his suspect chin and although he has the power to knock out just about everyone in the division, he can be knocked out as well. Have to give the nod to Adamek in this one.

Adamek. in my mind. would get beat by either of the Klitschkos, but I think he can beat most other fighters in the division. Haye, on the other hand, could possibly beat both Klitschkos with his combination of speed and power. But  his suspect chin also means could be ended just as quick. All of Haye’s three opponents have been at least 36; bubt it’s no fault of his own that his first defense was a mandatory against Ruiz.
It is good to see some worthy discussion finally happening in the heavyweight division. Although it will not happen anytime soon, it’d be nice to see Haye and Adamek square off, if they're around when the Klitschkos have departed.


 

More columns
by Rizwaan Zahid:

Joan Guzman: Best welterweight in the lightweight division

Devon Alexander/Female Boxing

Impressive U.S. debut for Campillo

Williams ready to punish at 147

Happy birthday, Champ!

Stars to Shine in 2010

The Grinches steal Christmas

Malignaggi-Diaz showed why instant replay is needed

Williams, Martinez show why they're avoided

Lucian Bute impresses America, and the world

James Kirkland: So promising, yet so wasteful

Suspension for foul language? That's bull$#:+!!!

Pacquiao-Cotto: Who wins?

Super Six Will Still Have Controversies

Haye, Angulo proved little

 

 

 

 


 

Listen to Rizwaan Zahid's commentary every Sunday on THE RINGSIDE BOXING SHOW

 

4 p.m. Pacific

5 p.m. Mountain

6 p.m. Central

7 p.m. Eastern

 

Worldwide via the Internet at www.krxa540.com
CLICK HERE for more information &
to hear Rizwaan Zahid and Travis Hartman
on THE RINGSIDE BOXING SHOW


 

Rizwaan Zahid



Born and raised in Toronto, Canada, Rizwaan Zahid is in his senior year at Carleton University in Ottawa, pursuing his Mass Communications degree, with the future aspirations of becoming a professional sports journalist.
Although relatively young, Rizwaan has shown his passion of writing the beautiful sport of boxing and has worked with Bragging Rights Corner, Boxing Banter, Diamond Boxing,
Fightfan.com, East Side Boxing as well as The Fight Network for over three years. With Fightfan.com, Rizwaan has been awarded the feature article of the month numerous times.
Over these past few years, Rizwaan has interviewed and conducted conferences with fighters and trainers such as Jeff Mayweather, Jermaine Taylor, Kelly Pavlik, Oscar De La Hoya, Roy Jones Jr., Jackie Kallen, Wayne McCullough, Manny Pacquaio, Wladimir Klitsckho and Emmanuel Steward.

Although boxing has been his main focus over the years, Rizwaan still has a strong passion for many other sports and has covered various sports in The Charlatan, Carleton University's newspaper.
Rizwaan has also worked with PHASE 1 Basketball, a camp based out of Toronto which is a showcase for the best basketball Canada has to offer on various levels, as well as the Out of Left Field blog which attracts numerous readers daily.

Rizwaan Zahid hopes to continue his efforts in journalism in the world of sports.
Contact Rizwaan